Warped Narratives
Distortion in the Framing of Gun Policy
How interest groups’ framing prevents solutions to gun violence
Description
The politics of gun policy in the United States are dramatic. Against the backdrop of daily gun violence—which claims more than 33,000 lives per year—gun control groups push for stronger regulations, while gun rights groups resist infringements upon their Second Amendment rights. To illuminate the dynamics of this polarized debate, Warped Narratives examines how and why interest groups frame the gun violence problem in particular ways, exploring the implication of groups’ framing choices for policymaking and politics. Melissa K. Merry argues that the gun policy arena is warped, and that both gun control and gun rights organizations contribute to the distortion of the issue by focusing on atypical characters and settings in their policy narratives. Gun control groups emphasize white victims, child victims, and mass shootings in suburban locales, while gun rights groups focus on self-defense shootings, highlighting threats to “law-abiding” gun owners. In reality, most gun deaths are the result of suicide. Homicides occur disproportionately in urban areas, mainly affecting racial minorities. While warping makes political sense in the short term, it may lead to negative, long-term consequences, including constraints on groups’ ability to build broad-based coalitions and to reduce prospects for compromise. To demonstrate warping, Merry analyzes nearly 67,000 communications by 15 national gun policy groups between 2000 and 2017 collected from blogs, emails, Facebook posts, and press releases. This book is the first to systematically assess the role of race in gun policy groups’ framing and offers the most comprehensive examination to date of interest groups’ presentation of this issue.
Melissa K. Merry is Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Louisville.
Reviews
“A unique and interesting project, one that will expand our understanding of this contentious political issue. Merry's sober insights offer a timely contribution to the unfolding legislative debates on guns.”
—Scott Melzer, Albion College
"... Merry takes a balanced position to thoroughly analyze how gun control and gun rights groups have framed this important subject for nearly two decades... makes a very convincing claim by the end of the book that policy warping is rampant in the communications from advocacy groups on both sides of this issue" - Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Books
- Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Books
"Merry has dived deeply and masterfully into the theoretical literature in the realms of messaging and gun policy and also understands well the contours of the gun debate... Merry has advanced and deepened our understanding of one of the most incendiary policy debates of our time."
- Robert J. Spitzer
—Perspectives on Politics
News, Reviews, Interviews
Listen: Melissa K. Merry interviewed by Susan Liebell about Warped Narratives on New Books Network | 7/10/20