". . .. [a] concise and provocative book for Roman historians. . . ."
—Michael C. Alexander, University of Illinois at Chicago, American Journal of Philology, Spring 2000
"This book is a polite challenge to a view of Roman Republican politics which prevailed in the late twentieth century. . . . Instead, he argues, Republican Rome was 'a variety of democracy/' His case is memorably presented and will have a lasting influence on debate [sic]."
—Anton Powell, University of Wales, Classical Review , Volume 50, No. 2 (2000)
". . . the importance of this book is manifold. Millar has firmly established the importance of openness in the workings of the Roman Republic, insofar as all public business was properly to be conducted in full view of the populous Romanus. The face-to-face nature of the ancient government has rarely been demonstrated more clearly. . . . No future study of the institutions and governance of the Republic, of the workings of Republican politics, or of the Roman ruling class can afford to ignore this book."
—Garrett F. Fagan, Penn State University, Echos du monde classique/Classical Views, Volume XLIII: No. 18, 1999
"This is a challenging work. . . . [I]t can confidently be said that the study of the Late Republic will never be the same again. That is some achievement."
—John Murrell, JACT Review, Summer 2003
"The lucidity of Millar's survey of the Roman notability's dealing with the populous acting in its 'historic role as audience, witness, an judge of what went on in the name of the Forum' in the years between 81 and 49 B.C. makes it accessible to all interested in Republican politics. . . ."
—A. J. E. Bell, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Journal of Roman Studies, Volume 90 (2000)
"Mr. Millar turns traditional interpretations [of Roman government] on their heads, using the corruption of democracy as evidence of its existence. That bribery was widespread demonstrates how essential popular assent was deemed to be for the exercise of political power."
—Paul Lewis, "Historians Give Romans Better Marks In Democracy", New York Times, July 24, 1998
". . . there can be no doubt that Millar has brought a multitude of insights to the study of the late Republic, and there can scarcely be any challenge to his redefinition of the central locus of Roman political activity. It is now clear that the most crucial setting for political decision making at Rome was not the curia but the Forum. . . ."
—Keith Bradley, University of Victoria, Phoenix, Volume 53 (1999)
"Millar presents us with detailed, interesting and sometimes brilliant analyses of speeches on the restoration of full tribunician powers. . . . It is Millar's interpretation of other speeches—some of them landmarks—and his reflections on the semantics of Republican political oratory and on the genius loci of the most 'hallowed' public space of the Republic that are worth further discussion. The debate on the political culture of Republican Rome must and will continue, and this book should stimulate it considerably."
—Karl-J. Hoelkeskamp, Uniiversitaet zu Koeln, Scripta Classica Israelica: Yearbook of the Israel Society for the Promotion of Classical Studies, 2000