The One and Only Law

Walter Benjamin and the Second Commandment
James R. Martel
A radical critique of contemporary legal practices and understandings based on a new consideration of Walter Benjamin’s “Critique of Violence”


Walter Benjamin’s “Critique of Violence,” widely considered his final word on law, proposes that all manifestations of law are false stand-ins for divine principles of truth and justice that are no longer available to human beings. However, he also suggests that we must have law—we are held under a divine sanction that does not allow us to escape our responsibilities. James R. Martel argues that this paradox is resolved by considering that, for Benjamin, there is only one law that we must obey absolutely—the Second Commandment against idolatry. What remains of law when its false bases of authority are undermined would be a form of legal and political anarchism, quite unlike the current system of law based on consistency and precedent.

Martel engages with the ideas of key authors including Alain Badiou, Immanuel Kant, and H.L.A. Hart in order to revisit common contemporary assumptions about law. He reveals how, when treated in constellation with these authors, Benjamin offers a way for human beings to become responsible for their own law, thereby avoiding the false appearance of a secular legal practice that remains bound by occult theologies and fetishisms.

“. . . a groundbreaking work that opens up a whole new field of research in which new and promising questions about Benjamin and law can be addressed. . . . Martel’s book makes Benjamin’s legal theory directly relevant to our theoretical and practical engagements with law in the present.”
—Marc de Wilde, Universiteit van Amsterdam

“Martel attempts to draw out an anarchist understanding of legal theory that goes beyond the banal rejection of law. . . . [This] book is very radical and potent.”
—Illan rua Wall, University of Warwick

Cover illustration: A painting of Walter Benjamin by Huguette Martel, based on a passport photo of Benjamin held by the Akademie der Künste, Berlin, Walter Benjamin Archiv. Used with permission of the artist and the Akademie der Künste, Berlin.

James R. Martel is Professor of Political Science at San Francisco State University. He is author of Textual Conspiracies: Walter Benjamin, Idolatry, and Political Theory (University of Michigan Press).

Look Inside

Product Details

  • 6 x 9.
  • 264pp.
Available for sale worldwide

  • Hardcover
  • 2014
  • Available
  • 978-0-472-07230-9

Add to Cart
  • $84.95 U.S.

  • Paper
  • 2014
  • Available
  • 978-0-472-05230-1

Add to Cart
  • $45.95 U.S.

Related Products



  • Walter Benjamin
    Alain Badiou
    Immanual Kant
    H.L.A. Hart
    Haitian revolution